Groupthink and gridlock in China's fifth generation

9

China’s new leaders have been vested with great hopes for reform but deep factional divisions in the Politburo mean real change will be elusive.

Comments on this article

Comments Policy
Robert Peterson,

Yes thank you Mr Lee. Upto your usual high standard. (Groupthink and gridlock in China's fifth generation, November 14)

Grant Musgrove,

This politics as normal, with the only exception that some countries have bottom up elections occasionally. (Groupthink and gridlock in China's fifth generation, November 14)

Greg Pringle,

My question would be: How do the 'princelings' and 'populists' line up on China's increasingly aggressive and nationalist (one might say expansionist) foreign policy? (Groupthink and gridlock in China's fifth generation, November 14)

Paran Ramakrishnan,

Could it be that we are falling into the trap of viewing China through the safety of our existing views? (Groupthink and gridlock in China's fifth generation, November 14)

Godfree Roberts,

To describe the world's most trusted, successful government (as shown in most domestic and international surveys) in this dismissive way suggests that the author is, indeed, determined to 'view China through the safety of our existing views'. (Groupthink and gridlock in China's fifth generation, November 14)
There is no evidence that the new team are any less flexible and pragmatic than their predecessors. Quite the contrary.

John Lord,

John, again a lengthy argument with good detail but always the negative conclusion (Groupthink and gridlock in China's fifth generation, November 14). I look forward to the day when you can see the country moving forward even slightly?
The last comment that we are looking at the new China through our existing views needs consideration.

Cedric Wade,

Slow reform leads to increasing pressure from th ever increasing pool of frustrated citizens....leading, inevitably, it seems, reading China's history,
to a revolution and installation of some rural warlord as premier. (Groupthink and gridlock in China's fifth generation, November 14)
It will happen again.

Jack Finch,

To me, the word "radical" conjures up images of Communist revolutions around the world, French revolution in France, and Great Culture Revolution in China (Groupthink and gridlock in China's fifth generation, November 15). Alexander Hamilton, one of founding fathers of America, strongly argued against radical change from the Westminster system. In fact, he believes that the Westminster system is the best ever political system being created by mankind and strongly argued that the new country - America, should continue use the Westminster system. China's present political system is very undesirable, but it doesn't warrant a radical change. Radical change is often based on ideology, ignoring all the practical problems. To those impatient radicals, I have to remind them social and political reforms are fraught with danger. The father of Taoism Laozi famously said to manage a big country is like cooking a small delicate fish.

Richard Lim,

In economy language, Mr.John Lee is squarely in the 'Perma-bear' camp (Groupthink and gridlock in China's fifth generation, November 14). Not a surprise considering he's the author of a book that sells on doom and gloom on China. What is impressive is the maturity of the readers to critically analyse the content. I certainly agree with Jack Finch that the last thing a big country like China needs is a large scale radical revolution!